Choosing the Right Plant Material for Bonsai
Almost any plant in the world can be trained as bonsai. But in practice, some species are far better suited than others. While you’ll find plenty of recommended species lists, don’t feel limited by them—bonsai is both horticulture and art. If a plant inspires you, try it. Who knows—you may break new ground in the bonsai world.
That said, not every plant will cooperate. If you’re determined to turn your zucchini or marigold into bonsai, you’ll face an uphill battle. Success comes from understanding what qualities make certain trees and shrubs ideal for bonsai training.
What Makes a Plant Suitable for Bonsai?
Bonsai artists typically look for two key traits when selecting plant material:
1. Naturally Small Leaves or Needles
There’s nothing in bonsai techniques that truly shrinks leaves or stops growth entirely. While container culture may reduce leaf size slightly (about 25%), species with naturally small foliage will always look more convincing.
For example:
- Scots pine or mugo pine are preferred over pitch pine because their needles are under 1 inch long.
- Chinese elm produces fingernail-sized leaves, unlike the American elm with much larger sized foliage.
Scale matters. A 6-inch bonsai with 4-inch leaves will look unnatural, while the same leaves might work beautifully on a 60†“imperial class†bonsai. The right choice depends on both species and artistic vision.
2. Ability to Bud on Old Wood
Most bonsai aren’t grown from seed. Instead, artists start with established material from nurseries, landscapes, or even collected from the wild. This raw stock is usually cut back hard to encourage new growth closer to the trunk.
For this to work, the plant must be able to “bud backâ€â€”producing fresh foliage on older wood. Species that don’t bud back well can still be trained, but require advanced techniques and patience.
Finding the Right Tree for You
Applying these two criteria still leaves thousands of possible species for bonsai. As a beginner, you may want to experiment with many of them. Over time, you’ll discover which trees naturally “work with you.â€
Each species has its own personality:
- Some bend easily under wiring; others snap at the slightest pressure.
- Some thrive in shallow pots; others struggle.
- Some tolerate extreme cold; others demand constant protection.
- Some are prone to pests; others are naturally hardy.
In this way, bonsai are very much like people—similar in structure, but each with unique strengths and quirks.
Beginner’s Tip: Start Simple
Since mistakes are part of the learning process, beginners should start with forgiving, resilient species. These trees allow you to practice wiring, pruning, and care without constant setbacks. As your skills grow, you’ll be ready to explore more challenging varieties and expand your bonsai collection.
Key Takeaway: The “best†bonsai material is the one that balances natural suitability (small foliage, ability to bud back) with your own artistic vision and skill level.
